I've just seen this exchange today, on reading through the various posts my conclusion would be that B A is finding it hard to accept the exponential decline of religion here in the UK and is striking back in his own way.
The point is no matter how much you don't like the decline in religious belief here in the UK, the fact remains religion is declining here in the UK, I do dislike religion but that's not the main reason I'm happy about its decline, it's the unnessary trouble it causes and it's unnessary in the first place.
I don't see that religion inspires good deeds with its carrot and pathetic stick approach, whether the people that do the good deeds are religious or not in my opinion, they are the sorts of people that would want to do good deeds anyway in spite of the rather odd aincent beliefs that are still managing to hang on here in this far more enlightened modern world.
ippy